Welcome to an Alternate Reality: Johnny Fairplay and The Ugly Girl from ANTM Are Having a Baby
September 10th, 2007 by Evil Beet
Can this be true?
I didn’t even know these two were dating.
Johnny Fairplay, that crazy dude from Survivor, and Michelle Deighton, the kind of ugly chick from Cycle 4 of ANTM, have been dating for two years, and now she’s pregnant.
Too weird.
Before you leave a comment, please make sure you've read our Guide to Commenting. It could save you a great deal of embarrassment.
She revealed on ANTM that she is a lesbian, didn’t she? Strange…
Didn’t this guy lie about his grandmother being dead on Survivor? And I thought she “came out” too. This could be a Z list publicity stunt. I’m just saying…
This girl is so damn annoying…..She cried every single episode at the judging. I NEVER thought this girl was pretty. She is so damn FUGLY. I loved the show until the season she was on there, I seriously could barely watch it because of her, she annoyed me that bad. OH YAH…..her hair looked hideous when they did their “Makeovers”, hers was terrible. Blonde wasnt good for her and her Gross Skin. She permanently was red in the face the whole season. I THOUGHT I WAS DONT SEEING YOUR FACE, GO AWAY PLEASE!!! Your so gross looking.
wow. she kind of looks like Lacey from Rock of Love. Not that I watch that.
Well that’s interesting!
Agree, majorfug!
Gross.
This girl is pretty, anyone who doesn’t feel that she is pretty or is saying she is ugly is just trying to hate.
Very beautiful girl, very interesting guy though
and she recovered from her eating disorder, i see?
I love how the people who are saying she’s ugly, and probably sitting at home digesting the rest of their ben n jerrys while watching reruns of seinfield probably
She’s ok looking very plain he’s the one who’s ugly anyway who the hell r they ?
Okay, she did look horrible with blonde hair, but i think she actually looks really pretty with dark hair, okay she obviously isnt having a baby with jonny fairplay. i watched that season of survivor and he is such a major asshole. also on a survivor reunion he brought his wifee..not her. she is also obviously not pregnant because she is a lesbo. kay if anyone else that stupid thinks she is then go ahead. and also i agree iwht “lovelin” because u guys are prob just fatasses who satay at home calling other people ugly to make urself look good. any other questions? good. thiss is all bullshit btw, because the person whoo made that rumor up is prob just bored with their life. kay peacout.